M&A

Managing the paranoia curve when selling your business

Jeremy KeithSpark Advisory

There is a pattern in every business sale I have ever worked on. Both parties start the process broadly optimistic. By the time they are close to signing, both are broadly suspicious. The deal itself has not changed. What has changed is the emotional temperature, and that temperature has a direct effect on how facts land.

I call this the paranoia curve.

What the curve describes

The curve is simple. Emotional intensity rises as deal day approaches. In the early stages, the buyer and seller are still in a form of courtship: both want it to work, both are inclined to give the benefit of the doubt. An issue disclosed at this point tends to be absorbed constructively. It gets discussed, it gets resolved, and the deal moves forward.

Let the same issue be found in due diligence rather than disclosed, and trust takes a knock: the buyer starts to wonder what else they have not been told, and the price comes under pressure. Disclose it later still, when the share purchase agreement is being negotiated and both sides have lawyers in the room, and the deal itself is at risk. The fact has not changed. The significance attributed to it has.

Same facts. Completely different outcomes.

The Paranoia Curve in M&AEmotional intensity rises from first conversation to deal day. The same issue is absorbed early, damages trust when it is found in diligence, and puts the deal at risk when it surfaces late.Emotional intensityFirst conversationDeal dayHoTsDDSPAEarly disclosureAbsorbed. Dealt with.Deal continues.Found, not disclosedTrust damaged. Price at risk.Same disclosure, laterAmplified reaction.Deal at risk.Recoverable zoneDanger zone
The paranoia curve. Three milestones mark the timeline: Heads of Terms, Due Diligence, and the Share Purchase Agreement. The later an issue surfaces, the more it costs.

What sellers get wrong

Some sellers are tempted to hold things back early, for fear that disclosure will cost them on price. In my experience, the opposite is usually true. Early disclosure, handled calmly, is almost always recoverable. Late disclosure, or discovery, is frequently not. It does not just affect the price. It contaminates the relationship that buyer and seller will need to sustain after the deal completes.

The instinct to delay is understandable. It is also, more often than not, exactly backwards.

What advisers are actually for

A good adviser will anticipate the issues before they surface and help the seller understand how and when to disclose them. That is not just process management. It is paranoia prediction: knowing what is coming, calibrating when on the curve it needs to land, and preparing both parties for the conversation before it becomes a confrontation.

A well-organised data room matters too. It signals to the buyer that the seller has nothing to hide, which keeps the temperature lower for longer. So do management accounts that already answer the questions a buyer will ask: revenue by client, recurring against one-off work, profit by service. When the monthly numbers have been telling the same story for a year, there is far less left to find in diligence, and far less for the curve to amplify.

The broader point

Understanding that paranoia is a structural feature of every deal, not a sign that something has gone wrong, changes how you navigate it. You cannot eliminate the curve. But you can be conscious of where you are on it, and that awareness alone will save deals that would otherwise fall apart in the final straight.