M&A

Why deals fail, and it is rarely the price

Jeremy KeithSpark Advisory

Roughly one in three business sales that reach a signed letter of intent never complete. Not deals that were idly explored. Deals that were agreed. A price shaken on, heads of terms drafted, both sides believing it was done. One in three of those still falls apart.

That number is a directional estimate rather than a hard fact, because no register tracks every private deal that quietly dies. But every experienced adviser recognises it, and it points at something sellers can get wrong about why deals fail.

The number is not where deals die

Ask a seller why a deal might collapse and they will talk about price. They assume the risk is that the parties cannot agree what the business is worth. In practice, that is the part that gets settled early, and settled amicably. Price is agreed in the optimistic phase, when both sides want it to work. The deal dies later, and it dies on something else.

The best recent data points the same way. Axial's study of 75 deals that broke in 2025 after a signed letter of intent found that diligence was the leading cause. A quarter died on issues found outside the accounts, such as legal, contract and customer problems, and a further fifth on earnings that did not survive a quality-of-earnings review. Together, that is nearly half. Another 15% died on renegotiations, often after those findings. That makes more than sixty percent. Not a disagreement about value. A discovery. The rest is a familiar list: sellers changing their minds, buyer financing that falls through, and a business that underperforms while the deal drags on.

Why agreed deals collapseOf deals that fail after a signed letter of intent, 61 percent trace to something the buyer found in diligence or the renegotiation that followed. The other 39 percent are seller decisions, financing, underperformance and other causes.Why agreed deals collapseShare of failures after a signed letter of intentFound in diligence, or renegotiated after itEverything else61%39%Seller decisions, financing,underperformance and otherOf deals that collapse after a signed letter of intent, more than 60% trace to what the buyer found indiligence or the renegotiation it triggered. Figures: Axial Dead Deal Report 2025 (75 deals), rounded.
Where agreed deals die. Deals die on what is found after the letter of intent is signed, not on the price agreed before it. Figures: Axial, Dead Deal Report 2025 (opens in a new tab). The reading is ours.

Found, not disclosed

Notice the common thread. These are rarely fatal problems in themselves. A business with one large client can still be sold. A founder the business depends on can still be sold around. What kills the deal is not the problem. It is that the problem was found rather than disclosed, and found late, when trust is thinnest and the buyer is most inclined to read the worst into it.

I have written before about the paranoia curve: the way emotional temperature rises as a deal progresses, so the same fact lands very differently depending on when it surfaces. A deal-killer discovered in diligence is that curve working against you. The issue itself might have been manageable in the first meeting. Discovered in week eight, unmentioned until the buyer's accountants dig it out, it reads as concealment, and concealment is what ends deals.

The asymmetry sellers do not see

There is a deeper reason preparation matters so much, and it comes down to a mismatch sellers sometimes miss.

You think your business is unique. To you it is. It is your life's work, and this is your one exit. The buyer does not see it that way. Their selection criteria are wider than you imagine, they are usually looking at several comparable targets at once, and they fully expect that some will fall away. When the data says one in three deals collapses, that is not a surprise to the buyer. It is planned for. Sophisticated buyers run targets in parallel precisely because they know attrition is coming.

That asymmetry changes everything after the letter of intent. A stumble that feels catastrophic to you is survivable to them, because they have somewhere else to go. It is also why the late price chip, the re-trade, works as reliably as it does. Sixty days into diligence, with legal fees mounting and your energy depleted, a buyer knocks a few percent off the price. You are exhausted and you have no alternative, so you take it. The buyer could walk. You usually cannot. That imbalance of walk-away power is the quiet engine behind most of what goes wrong late in a deal.

Why the preparation has to come first

All of which leads to the single most important thing a seller can understand. Once you have signed the letter of intent, you are on the buyer's clock, and the buyer has options. There is no grace period to fix what should already have been handled. So the work has to be done before you get there.

This is where I spend most of my effort, and it takes two forms.

The first is reverse diligence. Before a buyer ever runs their process on your business, I run it for you. We look at the company through the buyer's eyes, find the things that will get found, and surface, frame and fix them while they are still yours to control. The point is simple: nothing should be discovered in diligence, because everything has already been disclosed on your terms. That is the direct antidote to the found-not-disclosed problem, and it is worth far more than it costs, because a problem solved before the letter of intent is cheap, and the same problem discovered after it can cost you the deal. It is why Multiple Gap™ values each gap and checks what your monthly numbers can prove, not just the headline price.

The second is competitive tension. The buyer runs targets in parallel, so the seller's answer is to run buyers in parallel. Keeping a credible second bidder in the process removes the walk-away asymmetry. When the buyer knows you have somewhere else to go, the late re-trade loses most of its power, because for once you are not the only party who cannot walk.

Both of these have to be in place before the letter of intent. After it, it is too late to build either.

A number that survives diligence

None of this makes the valuation less important. You need to know what your business is worth, and why. But a valuation is only as strong as the evidence behind it. The number a buyer agrees in the optimistic phase is the number they will test in diligence, line by line, and the gap between the two is where deals die.

So the valuation and the preparation belong together. Know the number, know what is holding it down, and make sure your own monthly numbers prove it before a buyer's accountants go looking. A clean number is not a closed deal. A number that has already survived your own scrutiny is much closer to one.

The point

The number gets all the attention. It is the part everyone can see, argue about, and put in a headline. It is also, most of the time, not where deals die. Deals die on what is found, on how late it is found, and on an asymmetry of nerve that favours the prepared buyer over the unprepared seller.

So when you choose who advises you on a sale, ask how they will prepare you for the scrutiny that comes after the number is agreed, and how they will keep you from being the only person in the room who cannot walk away. That is where the deal is actually won or lost.